Woman’s complaint vs father’s tale: Gap remains in grey zone | Kolkata News
Woman’s complaint vs father’s tale: Gap remains in grey zone | Kolkata News

Woman’s complaint vs father’s tale: Gap remains in grey zone | Kolkata News

How did your country report this? Share your view in the comments.

Diverging Reports Breakdown

Woman’s complaint vs father’s tale: Gap remains in grey zone

The rape complaint emerging from one of India’s premier management institutes, followed by the family’s denial and the survivor’s apparent “hostility” to the case barely 12 hours later, shows how complicated this issue remains in some sections of society. From a feminist perspective, several structural, legal, social, and cultural changes have contributed to more women in India coming forward to report rape. However, these changes are complex, unevenly distributed, and still face significant patriarchal resistance.

Read full article ▼
1

2

3

Kolkata: The rape complaint emerging from one of India’s premier management institutes, followed by the family’s denial and the survivor’s apparent “hostility” to the case barely 12 hours later, shows how complicated this issue remains in some sections of society, say sociologists and women’s activists.From a feminist perspective, several structural, legal, social, and cultural changes have contributed to more women in India coming forward to report rape. However, these changes are complex, unevenly distributed, and still face significant patriarchal resistance.”We don’t know what happened in this instance. But it looks extremely unlikely that the woman would have been coerced by cops to file a complaint against a student of a premier B-school. This is not the first instance of a survivor of violence changing her statement,” remarked Anuradha Kapoor, founder of Swayam, a feminist organisation committed to ending gender inequality and violence against women, recounting past instances when women turned hostile to retract their statements — even video-graphed ones — against perpetrators.Psychologist Ratnabali Ray also felt it was extremely unlikely that the woman fabricated the complaint, as it takes a lot of courage for a survivor to walk into a police station and report a rape.”There are numerous instances when the survivor’s family has refused to support her complaint, citing concerns about honour and religious reputation. This underscores how deeply entrenched societal stigma and structural barriers can isolate victims of sexual violence. When fear of community shame outweighs compassion for a survivor, it reveals a dangerous culture of silence that leaves victims isolated and vulnerable,” said Ray.In the past couple of decades, there have been major initiatives to enable survivors to report the crime. But despite the gains, patriarchal resistance at the survivor’s home remains a formidable challenge.Kapoor says the reasons behind the decision could be multi-faceted: concern about how the police and doctors treat a survivor, the manner in which she is grilled by the defence lawyer in open court, the length of the trial, and the media glare.”Also, it is the family and the woman who have to face questions from neighbours and relatives and shoulder the blame and stigma. It is ironic that when a man commits the dishonourable act of rape, it is the woman who is said to lose her honour,” Kapoor said.

Source: Timesofindia.indiatimes.com | View original article

Source: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/womans-complaint-vs-fathers-tale-gap-remains-in-grey-zone/articleshow/122407349.cms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *