GOP Hardliners Challenge Speaker Mike Johnson’s Budget Plan

Speaker Mike Johnson’s proposed budget is facing threats from GOP hardliners who are demanding further cuts, posing a risk to kickstarting President Donald Trump’s agenda. Hours after the release of the House GOP’s compromise plan, conservatives with fiscal concerns are requesting more significant cuts than the proposed $1.5 trillion over a decade. This motion could jeopardize the support from the party’s centrist members, creating a fissure in the leadership’s plan.

Concerns from Fiscal Hawks

Several fiscal hawks in Congress have voiced their concerns about the current budget plan. The existing cuts are difficult for some Republican centrists to agree to, including Rep. Don Bacon of Nebraska, who hesitated to confirm his support for reductions of such magnitude.

• Rep. Andy Ogles, a Tennessee Republican, articulated his concerns: “As of right now the votes are not there,” suggesting that more negotiation is needed.
• Rep. Ralph Norman from South Carolina is also on the fence, indicating he wants guarantees in the final bill for policies like work requirements for Medicaid.
• Rep. Chip Roy of Texas and others on the Budget Committee have yet to express their positions, signaling the uncertainty surrounding the imminent committee vote.

Conservative Stance and Opportunities for Changes

The discussions hint at potential alterations in the budget plan during the markup session. Rep. Scott Perry, a member of the House Freedom Caucus, signaled the Conservatives’ intent to push for changes, although specifics remain under wraps for now. “We’re not done yet,” Perry said, suggesting ongoing possibilities for modulating the budget proposal.

Internal GOP Struggles: The Numbers Game

The resistance from the GOP’s hardliners is notable even after weeks of negotiations between Johnson’s leadership team and conservative members. Rep. Eric Burlison of Missouri, disparaged the spending cut target as “pathetic,” suggesting as many as six Republicans could reject the bill, a number sufficiently significant to upend the proposal due to Johnson’s tight votes margin. Rep. Eli Crane of Arizona echoed this sentiment, expressing dissatisfaction with the extent of proposed cuts.

Republican Allies and Leadership Confidence

Despite the opposition, Republican leadership remains optimistic about passing the budget. Rep. Dusty Johnson of South Dakota believes the budget represents a genuine compromise, albeit not without some “pain points” at both ends of the spectrum. According to Johnson, the strategy is to address legitimate concerns, with optimism for eventual success.

• The plan demands a cut in mandatory spending by at least $1.5 trillion, aiming for $2 trillion. However, conservatives demand a concrete $2 trillion target, voicing concerns otherwise.
• This necessitates potential savings in Medicaid, unsettling some centrist Republicans contemplating the steep cuts required.

Centrist Commitment and Trump’s Stance

Rep. Don Bacon and others are cautious about steep Medicaid cuts, echoing President Trump’s desire to avoid undermining it. “The speaker had a better plan,” Bacon remarked, recalling Johnson’s preliminary proposition of roughly $1 trillion in cuts, finding it a preferable point of compromise.

Similarly, Rep. Nick LaLota of New York emphasized the need for prudence concerning significant Medicaid and other program cuts, aligning with Trump’s directives against reducing Medicaid. “We have to be careful,” LaLota stressed, underscoring the necessity of cautious deliberation.

Conclusion: Navigating Internal Tensions

The discord within the GOP over budget cuts highlights a critical juncture. The leadership needs to artfully navigate between fiscal hawks demanding deeper cuts and centrists wary of overstepping, especially concerning programs like Medicaid.

As Johnson continues to lead these negotiations, the evolving debate underscores the complexities of reconciling varying Republican stances while steering the party’s broader legislative agenda. Will Speaker Johnson’s budget plan withstand the internal pressures and secure necessary support from within the GOP to advance President Trump’s initiatives? The upcoming committee and floor votes will be telling.

“`

Sources: https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/12/politics/gop-hardliners-revolt-mike-johnson/index.html