Barrett eviscerates Jackson, Sotomayor takes on a 'complicit' court in contentious final opinions
Barrett eviscerates Jackson, Sotomayor takes on a 'complicit' court in contentious final opinions

Barrett eviscerates Jackson, Sotomayor takes on a ‘complicit’ court in contentious final opinions

How did your country report this? Share your view in the comments.

Diverging Reports Breakdown

Barrett eviscerates Jackson, Sotomayor takes on a ‘complicit’ court in contentious final opinions

Justice Amy Coney Barrett said Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson took an “extreme” position on the role of the judiciary branch. In her Supreme Court opinion on nationwide injunctions on Friday, Barrett said Jackson’s dissent contained “rhetoric,” and she signaled that the liberal justice’s arguments were not worth much attention. The Supreme Court’s decision still allows for the high possibility that judges will continue to widely block Trump’s birthright citizenship order, but with different legal maneuvering on the part of the plaintiffs and the courts. Trump played a “different game,” Sotomayor said, by bringing the case before the Supreme Court without actually asking the justices to analyze the merits of his plan.

Read full article ▼
NEW You can now listen to Fox News articles!

Justice Amy Coney Barrett had pointed words for her colleague Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, accusing Jackson of taking an “extreme” position on the role of the judiciary branch.

Writing in her Supreme Court opinion on nationwide injunctions on Friday, Barrett said Jackson’s dissent contained “rhetoric,” and she signaled that the liberal justice’s arguments were not worth much attention.

“We will not dwell on Justice Jackson’s argument, which is at odds with more than two centuries’ worth of precedent, not to mention the Constitution itself,” Barrett wrote. “We observe only this: Justice Jackson decries an imperial Executive while embracing an imperial Judiciary.”

The Supreme Court’s decision came as part of an emergency request from the Trump administration asking the high court to put an end to judges issuing universal injunctions, including those that judges have placed on President Donald Trump’s birthright citizenship order.

TRUMP CELEBRATES SUPREME COURT LIMITS ON ‘COLOSSAL ABUSE OF POWER’ BY FEDERAL JUDGES

Barrett, who was appointed by Trump, wrote that when judges issue injunctions to block policies, like those the Trump administration is trying to implement, they cannot apply the injunction to more than the parties involved in the case. Barrett said that type of order, often called a “nationwide injunction,” is judicial overreach.

But Barrett’s opinion left open numerous other ways that plaintiffs can seek broad forms of relief from the courts, including by bringing class action lawsuits or statewide lawsuits.

SUPREME COURT CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS REINS IN SOTOMAYOR AFTER REPEATED INTERRUPTIONS

Jackson wrote that nationwide injunctions should be permissible because the courts should not allow the president to “violate the Constitution.” Barrett said that was not based on any existing legal doctrine.

“She offers a vision of the judicial role that would make even the most ardent defender of judicial supremacy blush,” Barrett wrote.

Sotomayor, meanwhile, wrote in her own dissenting opinion that the Supreme Court was being “complicit” by allowing the Trump administration to extract a perceived win out of the high court over birthright citizenship.

SUPREME COURT TAKES ON BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP: LIBERALS BALK AT TRUMP ARGUMENT TO END NATIONWIDE INJUNCTIONS

Sotomayor said that every court that has reviewed Trump’s birthright citizenship plan thus far has blocked Trump from carrying it out. Trump played a “different game,” Sotomayor said, by bringing the case before the Supreme Court without actually asking the justices to analyze the merits of his plan. Trump instead asked the justices to weigh in on the legality of nationwide injunctions in general.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Trump’s birthright citizenship order would eliminate the 150-year-old right under the 14th Amendment that allows babies born in the United States to receive automatic citizenship regardless of their parents’ citizenship status.

The Supreme Court’s decision still allows for the high possibility that judges will continue to widely block Trump’s birthright citizenship order, but with different legal maneuvering on the part of the plaintiffs and the courts.

Source: Foxnews.com | View original article

Source: https://www.foxnews.com/politics/barrett-eviscerates-jackson-sotomayor-takes-complicit-court-contentious-final-opinions

88 thoughts on “Barrett eviscerates Jackson, Sotomayor takes on a ‘complicit’ court in contentious final opinions”
  1. Индивидуалка приехала быстро, общение легкое, улыбка красивая. Массаж был очень нежным и возбуждающим. Чувствовал себя в центре внимания весь вечер. Советую, салон эротического массажа вызвать Новосиб – https://sibirki3.vip/. Отличный салон, атмосфера супер.

  2. best online pokies united states casino, slot machine australia
    and online poker for money usa, or mobile casino no deposit bonus usa

    my site … can you still get blackjack ointment (Lorene)

  3. casino game internet uk, usa blackjack online free and poker mat nz, or free spins no wagering requirements usa

    Feel free to surf to my website … what is tier in roulette (Chu)

  4. united statesn online casinos real money, legitimate online pokies australia and new
    casino 20 free spins (Loyd) spins
    no deposit online pokies canada, or uk bingo

  5. Заботьтесь о здоровье сосудов ног с профессионалом! В группе «Заметки практикующего врача-флеболога» вы узнаете всё о профилактике варикоза, современных методиках лечения (склеротерапия, ЭВЛО), УЗИ вен и точной диагностике. Доверяйте опытному врачу — ваши ноги заслуживают лучшего: https://phlebology-blog.ru/

  6. בטבעיות מוצאה. היא נראתה ראויה להשתתף בתחרות היופי, בהחלט. אולגה מצאה מיד שפה משותפת עם החברים דיסקרטיות נכנסו לסלון ואז נסחפו. טיפולי ספא, איפור, שיער ותוך שלוש שעות היינו בכוננות מלאה. קיטי https://liteporntube.com/

  7. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you
    knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was
    hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like
    this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and
    I look forward to your new updates.

    Have a look at my homepage: Blackjack rules Table

  8. Оптимизация сайта позволяет сделать ресурс более удобным для посетителей и привлекательным для поисковых систем. Работа с контентом, структурой страниц и внутренними ссылками помогает повысить позиции и удерживать их. Анализ конкурентов и корректировка стратегии обеспечивают стабильный рост. В итоге сайт привлекает больше заинтересованных клиентов и повышает доверие к бренду. Это эффективный инструмент для развития онлайн-проекта. Подробнее об этом читайте, https://dev.neos.epss.ucla.edu/wiki/index.php?title=Поисковая_Раскрутка_Сайта_Под_Ключ

  9. casino sites uk rtg no deposit bonus codes 2022 (Edith)
    deposit bonus, $10 deposit bonus casino nz and free spins no deposit uk low wagering,
    or casino united states age

  10. Грамотная SEO-стратегия позволяет вывести сайт на первые позиции и удерживать их долгое время. Оптимизация помогает улучшить структуру, контент и скорость загрузки страниц. В результате ресурс становится более удобным для пользователей и привлекательным для поисковых систем. Такой подход снижает зависимость от платной рекламы и обеспечивает долгосрочный результат. SEO помогает компаниям укреплять репутацию и повышать продажи. Узнайте больше о продвижении сайтов https://vote114.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=2987336

  11. Максимум качества, минимум травм. Профессиональные наборы для татуировки: машинки, блоки питания, премиум-краски. Всё для стерильной и крутой работы. Обновите свой арсенал сегодня https://tattoo-sale.ru/

  12. Входная дверь – это первый рубеж безопасности вашего жилища. Металлические входные двери сочетают в себе максимальную защиту от взлома, долговечность и современный дизайн, создавая надежный барьер между вашим домом и внешним миром: купить металлическую дверь в квартиру

  13. Ищете надежные входные металлические двери под ваши задачи и бюджет? Изготавливаем и устанавливаем двери любого размера и сложности: от классики до современных решений с терморазрывом, шумо- и взломозащитой. Премиальные стали, точная фурнитура, порошковая окраска, выбор отделки (МДФ, ламинация, паттерны), профессиональный замер за 1 визит и чистый монтаж за 1 день: стальная дверь

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *