Saints’ Quarterback Dilemma: Derek Carr’s Potential Surgery and Its Implications

The New Orleans Saints are facing a significant challenge as their quarterback situation is thrown into uncertainty. Reports have surfaced regarding the potential unavailability of Derek Carr for the 2025 NFL season due to a debilitating shoulder injury, as reported by NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport. The injury might require surgery, adding more complexity to the Saints’ quarterback roster.

Derek Carr’s Contract and the Cap Space Conundrum

Just a month ago, Derek Carr restructured his contract, creating $30.9 million in salary-cap space for the Saints in 2025, which conversely resulted in a cap number of $69.2 million for the subsequent year. This strategic move, while beneficial in the short term, casts a shadow over the Saints’ financial planning, especially with looming uncertainties concerning Carr’s health.

Previously, Carr’s 2024 season was cut short due to unfortunate injuries, including a fractured hand and concussion sustained in Week 14, after having already missed several games due to an oblique injury. These setbacks only serve to highlight the potential fragility of his professional future and its impact on the Saints.

Who Could Be the Next Starting Quarterback?

With Carr’s status up in the air, the Saints’ quarterback roster shapes up interestingly. The team currently houses:

• Spencer Rattler: A 2024 draft pick who experienced a tumultuous rookie season, concluding with an 0-6 record in place of Carr.
• Ben DiNucci and Jake Haener: Both have career backup status and do not provide the definitive leadership typically sought by a starting quarterback.

If the Saints opt to rely on their current roster, Rattler seemingly becomes the logical next choice. However, the franchise spotlights the possible addition of fresh talent through the upcoming NFL draft.

Draft Prospects and Financial Ramifications

The New Orleans Saints, holding the No. 9 pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, are speculated to be leaning towards drafting a new quarterback. However, prospects such as Miami’s Cam Ward might not be available by the time their pick arrives. Instead, the Saints find themselves in a favorable position, according to BetMGM odds, to draft Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders.

Such a move could potentially align with the Saints’ strategic goals, yet raises questions about how this would affect the team’s already strained salary cap. The Saints have long been a team wrestling with cap space issues and are projected to be over $25.9 million above cap for the 2026 season, as per OverTheCap data.

Void Years and Long-Term Planning

Derek Carr’s contract includes void years, meaning the financial restrictions imposed by his deal extend beyond his release or retirement. This adds another layer of complexity to the Saints’ future prospects. The ongoing cap challenges point towards a need for strategic restructuring and careful planning to ensure team stability and competitive capability.

The Road Ahead for the Saints

With Derek Carr’s potential surgery, the New Orleans Saints find themselves at a critical crossroads. The possibility of drafting a promising rookie quarterback like Shedeur Sanders offers hope, but it is accompanied by the substantial financial and strategic challenges typical of an NFL franchise navigating through uncertainty.

As the 2025 NFL season approaches, all eyes are on the Saints to see how they will tackle this dilemma of uncertainty, as they are set to make crucial decisions that will determine both their immediate and long-term futures on the football field.

The Saints face immense pressure not only to make the right calls in terms of player health and draft picks but also to manage their financial strategy without crippling the team’s potential growth. The coming months will be pivotal for the franchise as they strive to maintain relevance in the competitive landscape of the NFL.

Decisions made now will echo into the coming seasons, and the ability of the Saints to pivot effectively could set the precedent for their success or struggles in the future.

“`

Source: https://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/article/saints-qb-derek-carrs-availability-for-2025-reportedly-in-doubt-due-to-shoulder-injury-could-need-surgery-210454780.html