
NFL tush push vote: Which teams voted for, against banning controversial Eagles play?
How did your country report this? Share your view in the comments.
Diverging Reports Breakdown
NFL tush push vote: Which teams voted for, against banning controversial Eagles play?
A proposal to ban the tush push failed to pass Wednesday at the NFL’s owners meetings in Eagan, Minnesota. The proposal received 22 out of 32 votes, falling two short of approval. The Eagles were the most vocal about their opposition to the ban, but personnel with other teams seemed more on board with the idea. All but one team that plays against the Eagles in 2025 voted to ban it. The Packers are the least surprising team on that list, as they were the franchise that proposed the ban in the first place. The other two teams that stand out among that group are the Cardinals and Colts, both of which employ former Eagles coordinators as their current head coaches. The Saints were among the 10 teams to vote against the ban Wednesday, meaning Kellen Moore is probably a safe bet to receive a holiday card from Nick Sirianni this winter.
That was far from certain heading into the day. While the Eagles were the most vocal about their opposition to the ban — for obvious reasons — personnel with other teams seemed more on board with the idea.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
In the end, the Eagles won that fight … but barely. The proposal — which needed 24 votes to pass — received 22 out of 32 votes, falling two short of approval.
So, which teams voted for and against the policy? We know the answer to that thanks to ESPN’s Adam Schefter, and it’s a fascinating list.
The following 10 teams reportedly saved the tush push by voting against the proposal:
Philadelphia Eagles
Baltimore Ravens
Cleveland Browns
Detroit Lions
Jacksonville Jaguars
Miami Dolphins
New England Patriots
New Orleans Saints
New York Jets
Tennessee Titans
Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones tried to play it coy when asked how he voted, but it appears he was out to stick it to his division rival.
Jones isn’t the only member of the NFC East to make the decision. Both the New York Giants and Washington Commanders reportedly voted to ban the play. All three of those clubs have to play the Eagles twice in the regular season, and have likely seen their fair share of tush pushes over the years.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
On a similar front, all but one team that plays against the Eagles in 2025 voted to ban the tush push. That would be the Lions, who are perfectly fine with the tush push sticking around. Detroit and Philadelphia square off in Week 11.
Assuming Schefter’s list is accurate, the following 22 teams voted in favor of a tush push ban.
Arizona Cardinals
Atlanta Falcons
Buffalo Bills
Carolina Panthers
Chicago Bears
Cincinnati Bengals
Dallas Cowboys
Denver Broncos
Green Bay Packers
Houston Texans
Indianapolis Colts
Kansas City Chiefs
Las Vegas Raiders
Los Angeles Chargers
Los Angeles Rams
Minnesota Vikings
New York Giants
Pittsburgh Steelers
San Francisco 49ers
Seattle Seahawks
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Washington Commanders
The Packers are the least surprising team on that list, as they were the franchise that proposed the ban in the first place.
The other two teams that stand out among that group are the Cardinals and Colts. Both clubs employ former Eagles coordinators as their current head coaches. Shane Steichen joined the Colts in 2023 after serving as the Eagles’ offensive coordinator. Jonathan Gannon joined the Cardinals in the same year after serving as the Eagles’ defensive coordinator.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
Prior to Wednesday’s vote, Steichen confirmed Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni reached out to try and sway how the Colts would vote. Steichen said he was in favor of keeping the play, but the Colts voted against it.
It’s worth noting coaches did not vote on Wednesday’s proposal. That responsibility fell to team owners. So while Steichen may have been in favor of keeping the tush push around, Colts owner Jim Irsay apparently did not agree. Even so, it could make for a slightly awkward situation the next time Sirianni sees his former coordinators.
That awkwardness won’t extend to former Eagles offensive coordinator Kellen Moore. After helping lead the Eagles to a Super Bowl win, Moore was hired as the Saints’ next head coach. The Saints were among the 10 teams to vote against the ban Wednesday, meaning Moore is probably a safe bet to receive a holiday card from Sirianni this winter.
Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie reportedly likened tush-push opposition to ‘wet dream,’ drawing ire of NFL’s Troy Vincent
Philadelphia Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie argued for the tush push at Wednesday’s NFL owners meeting. He reportedly called the proposal to ban the play “like a wet dream for a teenage boy” The vote to ban it fell two votes short of the 3/4 majority needed to bring its end. Nine other teams joined the Eagles in voting to keep the play legal, enough to thwart the proposed ban.Twenty-two out of 32 NFL teams voted in favor of banning the play, where 24 votes were needed to change the rulebook. And a team that in part just rode the tushes push to a Super Bowl championship will push on in the new NFL season.
And it didn’t come without some last-minute and reportedly lurid wrangling from Philadelphia Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie at Wednesday’s NFL owners meetings in Minneapolis.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
Per multiple reports, Lurie held court during a lengthy speech ahead of a vote of owners on a proposal to ban the play that helped propel the Eagles to a Super Bowl victory in February. The pre-vote meeting also featured a plea from Jason Kelce, who was for years the centerpiece of the tush push as Philadelphia’s All-Pro center.
According to ESPN and The Athletic, Lurie spent roughly an hour arguing to fellow owners that the tush push should survive. Per both reports, Lurie took a, ahem, candid approach to making his case.
Lurie told his fellow owners that other teams’ efforts to ban the play that they otherwise overwhelmingly can’t stop was “like a wet dream for a teenage boy.”
That’s one way to put it. And one way to explain why “tempers flared” during the meeting, per ESPN’s account. According to ESPN, Lurie’s “wet dream” analogy drew the ire of NFL executive vice president of football operations Troy Vincent, who reportedly chastised Lurie for making the comment in front of women in the room.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
It’s worth noting that Vincent was a proponent of the tush-push ban. And Lurie reportedly criticized him and commissioner Roger Goodell for their support of the ban during the meeting.
Philadelphia Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie has a lot to smile about lately. (Kara Durrette/Getty Images) (Kara Durrette via Getty Images)
In his plea, Lurie reportedly shot down arguments that the tush push presents an increased risk of player safety. In fact, he called it “the safest play in the history of the game.”
While that might be an overstatement, there’s no established data to demonstrate that the tush push directly leads to an increased risk of injury — even if the Green Bay Packers made player safety the centerpiece of their proposal to ban it.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
The length of Lurie’s plea grew weary for at least one fellow owner. Per ESPN, San Francisco 49ers owner Jed York asked Lurie “how much more s***” he needed to say as the speech crossed the one-hour mark. But ultimately, Lurie’s speech may have proven worthwhile. Nine other teams joined the Eagles in voting to keep the tush push legal, enough to thwart the proposed ban.
Wednesday was expected to be the death knell for the short-yardage play that frequently results in a first-down or touchdown sneak for Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts. But the vote to ban it fell two votes short of the 3/4 majority needed to bring its end.
Twenty-two out of 32 NFL teams voted in favor of banning the play, where 24 votes were needed to change the rulebook. And a team that in part just rode the tush push to a Super Bowl championship will push on in the new NFL season. It’s taking a victory lap in the meantime.
Kellen Moore will get to bring Eagles’ signature play to New Orleans after all
The New Orleans Saints brought in former Philadelphia Eagles offensive coordinator Kellen Moore to be their next head coach. The tush push is one of the NFL’s most controversial plays ever. Many teams have tried to replicate it, but with little success. The Green Bay Packers submitted a proposal at the spring meeting that needed 24 votes to pass. The final vote was 22-10, meaning the play lives on.
That really brings one specific play to mind: the tush push. One of the NFL’s most controversial plays ever, Philadelphia has been using it to almost automatically win short-yardage situations for the last few years. Many teams have tried to replicate it, but with little success.
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
If there was anyone that would have some insight into how to pull it off, though, it would be the former offensive coordinator. Moore didn’t invent the tush push but he did see it firsthand in Philadelphia.
Before ever getting a chance to run it with the Saints, though, the play almost got banned this offseason. The Green Bay Packers submitted a proposal at the spring meeting that needed 24 votes to pass. ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported that the final vote was 22-10, meaning the play lives on. Moore will be able to bring it to New Orleans, if he so wishes.
It isn’t a 100% given that the coach will have the Saints run it this year, though.
“I don’t know, we’ll see. Obviously, I think other teams have tried to replicate it and have not had success. It’s a huge investment to execute that play at a really high level, and ]the Eagles] put a lot of time and effort into it,” said Moore per Locked On Saints host Ross Jackson.
This article originally appeared on Saints Wire: Kellen Moore can bring Eagles’ signature play to New Orleans after all
Saints passed one of the deciding votes to save the Eagles’ tush push
The New Orleans Saints were one of ten teams who voted in favor of keeping the play. The Eagles’ signature “tush push” play lives to frustrate defenses another day. If the Saints had voted to ban the tush push, all it would have taken was another one of those nine teams to follow them. Instead, it’ll continue to make a difference in today’s game. It’s good to see the Saints are on the right side of this.
But they only got 22. The Saints were one of ten teams who voted in favor of keeping the play, per ESPN’s Adam Schefter:
Advertisement
Advertisement Advertisement
Philadelphia Eagles
New Orleans Saints
Baltimore Ravens
Cleveland Browns
Detroit Lions
Jacksonville Jaguars
Miami Dolphins
New England Patriots
New York Jets
Tennessee Titans
So that’s nine teams (and the Eagles) who aren’t scared to compete. If you can’t run the play yourself, practice it until you can. If you can’t stop it, don’t try to litigate it out of the sport because your team isn’t up to the challenge. Clearly the Saints are on the right side of this, which is good to see. If the Saints had voted to ban the tush push, all it would have taken was another one of those nine teams to follow them. Instead, it’ll continue to make a difference in today’s game.
The Saints voting in favor of the play is expected given everyone’s past comments. First-year Saints head coach Kellen Moore has said it takes “a huge investment to execute that play at a really high level” while his old boss and Eagles counterpart Nick Sirianni said that “Moore better vote for it” along with his other assistants-turned-head coaches around the league. Ironically, Moore’s team did cast one of the two ballots to keep the play legal, while neither the Arizona Cardinals (coached by Sirianni’s former defensive coordinator Jonathan Gannon) nor the Indianapolis Colts (coached by Shane Steichen, Moore’s predecessor as offensive coordinator) did. Ultimately, Moore and the Saints helped it get across the finish line.
This article originally appeared on Saints Wire: Tush push vote: Saints had key role in saving Eagles’ signature play
Source: https://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/article/nfl-tush-push-vote-which-teams-voted-for-against-banning-controversial-eagles-play-184451569.html