Donald Trump’s Pledge to Reinstate the Death Penalty Explored

President-elect Donald Trump has once again broached a topic that has long been a part of his political discourse: the use of the death penalty. His recent statement promising the Department of Justice will “vigorously pursue the death penalty” touches on a controversial subject that is sure to evoke mixed reactions across the country.

Trump’s Announcement Following Biden’s Commutations

In the wake of President Joe Biden’s decision to commute the death sentences of 37 federal inmates, Trump has vowed to counteract this move by renewing the federal government’s commitment to capital punishment. Trump’s declaration reflects his long-standing advocacy for a strict approach to dealing with violent crime and aligns closely with his law-and-order campaign rhetoric.

The Controversy Behind Capital Punishment

The issue of the death penalty remains divisive in America:

• Human Rights Concerns: Critics of capital punishment often highlight human rights concerns, arguing that it is inhumane and subject to judicial errors.
• Deterrence, Cost, and Ethics: Proponents argue that it serves as a deterrent to serious crimes, despite studies showing conflicting outcomes regarding its effectiveness.
• Financial Cost: The expense involved in executing a person, which often exceeds the cost of life imprisonment due to lengthy and complex legal processes.

On Tuesday, Trump announced on Truth Social that once inaugurated, he plans to ensure the Justice Department resumes rigorous enforcement of the death penalty for “violent rapists, murderers, and monsters,” albeit a small number of federal inmates remain under such a sentence.

Rationale for Trump’s Advocacy

Donald Trump has consistently linked the death penalty to his broader strategy against violent crime and illegal activities. His rhetoric extends beyond just murder, advocating for capital punishment as a penalty for other severe crimes, such as:

• Drug Trafficking: Trump has vowed to target drug dealers, pushing for the death penalty as a fitting punishment.
• Human Trafficking: He strongly believes individuals involved in severe human trafficking crimes should face the maximum permissible punishment under law.

The Impact of Biden’s Commutations

Biden’s recent commutations have temporarily removed a large portion of individuals from federal death row, leaving only three high-profile convicts facing execution, all involved in mass shootings or terrorist attacks:

• Robert Bowers, responsible for the 2018 Pittsburgh synagogue shooting.
• Dylann Roof, a White nationalist who murdered nine people in Charleston in 2015.
• Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, implicated in the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing.

Biden’s decisions can’t be reversed by Trump when he takes office, but his administration could sharpen its focus on pursuing such sentences moving forward.

Mixed Reactions to Commutations and Restored Death Penalty

The response to Biden’s commutations has been mixed, with relief from some family members of the commuted inmates but also anger from victims’ families. Marissa Gibson, the widow of a slain police officer, voiced disappointment in Biden’s clemency decision, emphasizing the irreversible impact of violent crime.

The call for the death penalty stirs emotional responses nationwide, influencing political discourse and public opinion. Critics and advocates are expected to dominate conversations as Trump and his administration lay out what it means to reportedly become a “Nation of Law and Order.”

A Look Back: Federal Executions in the Trump Era

During Trump’s first presidency, though federal executions were rare, he authorized 10 executions, reinstating an active federal death penalty policy for the first time in 17 years. This decision starkly contrasts Biden’s administration’s current philosophy towards capital punishment.

Looking Forward: Capital Punishment’s Role in Upcoming Policy

As Trump’s administration begins its approach in January, focus will remain not only on the federal system but also on the broader implications of this renewed legal stance. The efforts to seek the death penalty could reflect Trump’s strong direction against violent and heinous crimes, further influencing debates over morality, legality, and public safety.

The political landscape around capital punishment is likely to undergo significant scrutiny, with an equally probable rise in advocacy and activism from entities opposing and supporting this form of justice.

The definition of justice under Trump’s proposed regulations aims for high visibility and debate—both in U.S. domiciles and international spheres equally interested in how America’s justice reform unfolds in the newly defined legal framework.

“`

Sources: https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/24/politics/trump-death-penalty/index.html