U.K. parliament votes to bar prosecution for abortions in England and Wales
How did your country report this? Share your view in the comments.
Diverging Reports Breakdown
U.K. Parliament votes to bar prosecution for abortions in England, Wales
British lawmakers vote 379 to 137 in favor of decriminalizing abortion after 24 weeks. It is the biggest change to abortion laws in England and Wales in decades. It follows an increase in recent years in investigations and prosecutions of people suspected of having illegal abortions. Critics of the amendment argued that it would effectively legalize self-induced abortion at any point up until birth. But polls also show that most people don’t support extending the legal time limit beyond 24 weeks’ gestation.“There must be no more Nicola Packers,” Labour lawmaker Tonia Antoniazzi told the House of Commons on Tuesday. “Listen to our American counterparts who regret having not acted under the 1861 Offences against the Person Act,’” she said. ‘Listen to medics who now find themselves with medics being prosecuted and dragged across state lines and dragged down by the courts.’ ‘‘I am not a criminal. I am a human being. I have a right to an abortion.”
Abortion in England and Wales is illegal under the 1861 Offences against the Person Act — a Victorian-era law that makes abortion a criminal offense that carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. That bill was written at a time when women could not vote, own property after marriage, or access higher education.
Tuesday’s vote follows an increase in recent years in investigations and prosecutions of people suspected of having illegal abortions.
Advertisement
That abortion is technically illegal in England and Wales surprises many people, including those living here, as access to the procedure is widespread. The amended 1967 Abortion Act carved out exceptions, allowing abortions at up to 24 weeks if approved by two doctors. But outside of specific criteria, it is still a criminal offense.
Tuesday’s vote will remove the criminal penalties for having an abortion, even outside of these parameters.
Tonia Antoniazzi, the Labour lawmaker who championed the amendment, said it was a “once in a generation” opportunity and the “right change at the right time.” Antoniazzi also insisted that the rules under the 1967 act for how abortion services are provided will not change.
Until recent years, prosecutions were almost unheard of. But campaigners say that around 100 women over the past decade were investigated for suspected unlawful abortions. Since December 2022, six have been charged.
Advertisement
Among them was Nicola Packer, 45, who was arrested in a hospital after taking abortion pills during the coronavirus lockdown. She denied knowing that she was 26 weeks pregnant. Four years later, after a trial in which intimate details of her personal life were examined, a jury found her not guilty. But the case sparked calls to update abortion laws.
“There must be no more Nicola Packers,” Antoniazzi told the House of Commons on Tuesday.
Louise McCudden, U.K. head of external affairs for MSI Reproductive Choices, one of Britain’s biggest abortion providers, called the prosecutions “a real anomaly in our law. Even in places like Texas, they don’t tend to prosecute the woman herself.”
“The investigations themselves have been horrific,” McCudden said. “In some cases, women have been separated from their children, their names made public, they’ve received death threats, they didn’t take pills but had a stillbirth or a miscarriage.”
Advertisement
The rise of investigations coincided with a legal change that allowed access to abortion pills that can be taken at home at up to 10 weeks of pregnancy.
Surveys show that the overwhelming majority of Britons favor making abortion legal. But polls also show that most people don’t support extending the legal time limit beyond 24 weeks’ gestation.
Critics of the amendment argued that it would effectively legalize self-induced abortion at any point up until birth.
Rebecca Paul, a Conservative member of Parliament, told the House of Commons that the change would mean “fully developed babies up to term could be aborted by a woman with no consequences.”
In interviews, abortion care doctors said that they will still be bound by the same rules as before – including the 24-week limit in most cases, mandatory legal forms, and the requirement of two signatures – and that they could face prosecution if they do not adhere to them.
Advertisement
Many European countries in recent years have expanded abortion rights. Denmark and Norway recently extended the legal limit from 12 to 18 weeks. Last year, France enshrined abortion as a “guaranteed freedom” into its constitution, and Ireland liberalized its laws after a public referendum in 2018.
Other countries have maintained or tightened access. The current Polish government has failed to deliver on a pledge to liberalize the country’s extremely restrictive laws. In 2022, Hungary made it mandatory for those seeking an abortion to listen to fetal vital signs.
Campaigners on both sides of the debate have said they have been energized by the rollback of abortion rights in the United States.
Stella Creasy, a Labour lawmaker who has been pushing for a more comprehensive reform of abortion law, told Parliament on Tuesday: “Listen to our American counterparts who bitterly regret not having acted under Biden and Obama … and now find themselves with medics being prosecuted and dragged across state lines.”